My Heaps Don't Lie
Or How To Identify and Solve Any Priority Queue Problem
Priority queues and heaps are fundamental data structures that frequently appear in coding interviews. They might seem daunting at first, but once you understand how they work and how to apply them, you'll feel lucky to receive a priority queue interview question because of how easy it is to solve them.
In this issue, we’ll break down the essentials of priority queues and heaps, explore common problem patterns, and provide a step-by-step approach to help you tackle any heap-related problem.
Priority Queues vs Heaps
Let’s first clarify the difference between Priority Queues and Heaps.
tldr: Priority Queue is an idea of a data structure and Heaps are a concrete data structure that is the most common implementation of a Priority Queue.
What Is a Priority Queue?
A priority queue is an abstract data type similar to a regular queue or stack, but with an additional feature: each element has a "priority" associated with it. In a priority queue, elements are served based on their priority, not just their insertion order.
What Is a Heap?
A heap is a specialized tree-based data structure that satisfies the heap property:
Max-Heap: In a max-heap, for any given node
C, the value ofCis less than or equal to the value of its parentP. The highest value is at the root.Min-Heap: In a min-heap, the value of
Cis greater than or equal to the value of its parentP. The lowest value is at the root.
Heaps are commonly used to implement priority queues because they allow for efficient retrieval and modification of the highest or lowest priority element. In practice, the two terms are often used interchangeably, but not by you - because now you know the difference.
When to Use Heaps: The Key Indicator
One of the biggest giveaways that heaps are appropriate is when the problem involves dynamic or streaming data. Heaps allow you to process incoming data as it arrives and provide the ability to query for the maximum or minimum value at any time. When the data is static, it is often sufficient to use a sorting algorithm. However, for dynamic datasets where elements are continually added or removed, heaps offer efficient O(log n) insertion and deletion operations, making them ideal for maintaining order in real-time.
Common Problem Patterns Involving Heaps
1. Kth Largest/Smallest Element
Scenario: If the problem asks for the Kth largest or smallest element in a collection, heaps are ideal since they allow efficient insertion and extraction of the minimum or maximum element.
Example: "Find the Kth largest number in a stream."
Approach:
Dynamic Data: Since the data may be continuously updated, a heap allows you to maintain the K largest elements efficiently.
Implementation: Use a min-heap of size
kto keep track of the topklargest elements in real-time.
LeetCode Example: 703. Kth Largest Element in a Stream
2. Merging or Sorting Multiple Lists
Scenario: Problems that require merging multiple sorted lists or arrays can often be optimized using a heap. This allows you to keep track of the smallest (or largest) element from each list and merge efficiently.
Example: "Merge k sorted linked lists into one sorted list."
Approach:
Dynamic Selection: A heap helps you dynamically select the next smallest element among the heads of the lists.
Implementation: Use a min-heap to store the current smallest element from each list.
LeetCode Example: 23. Merge k Sorted Lists
3. Frequent Elements
Scenario: If you're asked to find the top K most frequent elements or similar problems involving frequency and ranking, heaps can be used to efficiently maintain the top K elements as you process the data.
Example: "Find the top K most frequent words in a list of words."
Approach:
Dynamic Counting: While the data may be static, heaps allow for efficient retrieval of the top frequencies without sorting the entire frequency map.
Implementation: Use a min-heap of size
kto keep track of the top K elements based on frequency.
LeetCode Example: 692. Top K Frequent Words
4. Dynamic Minimum/Maximum
Scenario: Any problem where you need to repeatedly access the minimum or maximum element in a dynamic dataset (inserting and removing elements) is a strong indicator for using a heap.
Example: "Design a data structure that supports inserting numbers and retrieving the maximum number at any time."
Approach:
Dynamic Data: As elements are added or removed, the heap maintains the ordering.
Implementation: Use a max-heap to maintain the maximum element.
LeetCode Example: 716. Max Stack
5. Scheduling or Task Execution
Scenario: If the problem involves scheduling tasks based on priorities or deadlines, a priority queue can help efficiently pick the next task to execute based on priority.
Example: "Given tasks with deadlines and durations, find the optimal schedule to maximize completed tasks."
Approach:
Dynamic Selection: Tasks may be added or priorities may change; a heap allows for efficient retrieval of the highest priority task.
Implementation: Use a heap to select the next task based on priority criteria (e.g., earliest deadline).
LeetCode Example: 621. Task Scheduler
6. Sliding Window Problems
Scenario: Problems where you need to track the maximum or minimum value in a sliding window (e.g., "find the maximum in each sliding window of size K") often benefit from heaps to efficiently maintain the range's top elements.
Example: "Find the maximum number in each sliding window of size K in an array."
Approach:
Dynamic Window: As the window slides, elements enter and exit the window dynamically.
Implementation: Use a max-heap to keep track of the maximum element in the current window, taking care to discard elements that are no longer in the window.
LeetCode Example: 239. Sliding Window Maximum
7. Shortest Path or Minimum Spanning Tree
Scenario: Graph-related problems like Dijkstra’s algorithm (for shortest paths) or Prim’s algorithm (for minimum spanning trees) make heavy use of priority queues to efficiently find the next node with the smallest cost.
Example: "Find the shortest path from a source node to all other nodes in a weighted graph."
Approach:
Dynamic Edge Weights: The priority queue (min-heap) allows for efficient selection of the next node with the smallest tentative distance.
Implementation: Use a min-heap to store nodes with their current shortest distance estimates.
LeetCode Example: 743. Network Delay Time
8. Order Statistics
Scenario: When the problem requires maintaining some sort of running order statistic, such as finding the median in a dynamic stream of numbers.
Example: "Design a data structure that supports adding numbers and finding the median."
Approach:
Dynamic Median: As new numbers come in, the median can change.
Implementation: Use two heaps—a max-heap for the lower half and a min-heap for the upper half—to maintain balance and efficiently compute the median.
LeetCode Example: 295. Find Median from Data Stream
Step-by-Step Approach to Solving Heap Problems
Step 1: Understand the Problem Thoroughly
Read Carefully: Ensure you understand what the problem is asking.
Identify Clues: Look for scenarios involving dynamic or streaming data, need for frequent access to min/max elements, or maintaining top K elements.
Step 2: Determine If a Heap Is Appropriate
Dynamic Data: If the data is dynamic (elements are added or removed over time), a heap is likely appropriate.
Real-Time Queries: If you need to query for the max or min at any time during data updates, consider using a heap.
Static Data: If the data is static and all you need is to find min/max or sort once, a sorting algorithm may suffice.
Step 3: Choose the Right Type of Heap
Min-Heap vs. Max-Heap:
Min-Heap: Access the smallest element.
Max-Heap: Access the largest element.
Combination:
Some problems require both (e.g., maintaining medians).
Step 4: Decide on the Programming Language and Libraries
Python: Use the
heapqmodule (min-heap). For max-heap, invert the values.Java: Use
PriorityQueueclass. For max-heap, provide a custom comparator.C++: Use
priority_queuefrom STL. Default is max-heap.Ruby: Unfortunately heaps are not available in the standard Ruby libraries. Some platforms like Leetcode have the
algorithmsgem readily available but there is no guarantee that it will be available for you during your interview. I personally would make an assumption that there is some MaxHeap/MinHeap data structure available and then will implement it myself at the end if time permits.
Step 5: Implement the Solution
Initialize the Heap: Build the heap with initial elements if any.
Perform Heap Operations:
Insertion: Add elements as they come.
Deletion: Remove elements based on problem logic.
Peek: Access the top element without removing it.
Tips and Tricks
1. Dynamic vs. Static Data
Dynamic Data: When dealing with data that changes over time (insertions, deletions), heaps provide efficient O(log n) operations for maintaining order.
Static Data: If the dataset doesn't change, sorting algorithms (O(n log n)) may be more straightforward and sometimes more efficient for one-time processing.
2. Be Mindful of Element Indices
In problems like sliding window maximum, store indices along with values to know when to discard elements that are no longer within the window.
3. Simulating Max-Heap in Min-Heap Languages
In languages like Python, which only provide a min-heap, invert the values to simulate a max-heap.
heapq.heappush(max_heap, -num)4. Combine Heaps with Other Data Structures
Sometimes, heaps alone may not suffice. Combining them with hash maps, deques, or other data structures can solve more complex problems.
5. Practice Standard Problems
Familiarize yourself with classic heap problems to recognize patterns quickly.
Summing Up
Mastering priority queues and heaps equips you with a powerful tool to efficiently solve a variety of problems that involve ordering, scheduling, and dynamically tracking extrema in datasets. These types of problems are quite frequent in coding interviews at top tech companies. Make sure to practice the problems referenced above as well as other problems tagged as “Heap”.
Stay curious and happy coding!
Nurbo
I'm Accepting New Mentees!
Are you looking for a mentor to guide you and keep you accountable on your tech interview preparation journey? I'm here to help.
I'm opening up a few spots for motivated individuals who would benefit from weekly one-on-one mentorship sessions. Together, we'll:
Develop a personalized study plan
Master problem-solving techniques
Build confidence for your interviews
Ready to take your preparation to the next level? Book a free introductory session with me here.